PLANS - Articles About Waldorf, Steiner, Anthroposophy

Rudolf Steiner Photo

Articles, Research and Personal Stories

Thomas Jefferson Portrait

Black Ink Brush Stroke

Criticism of Waldorf, Steiner and Anthroposophy PLANS tries to make available all the critical opinions about Waldorf that we can find. The authors are responsible for the contents of the following articles. PLANS does not necessarily agree with or vouch for the veracity of everything posted in this section. Click a link below to jump to a section. Use your browser's Back button to return from external links. Waldorf in General, Description & Critique Personal Stories of Former Waldorf Parents, Students, Teachers, Administrators Quotations About Waldorf and Anthroposophy by Rudolf Steiner and Others Waldorf Curriculum and Anthroposophy in the Classroom Waldorf Teacher Training Anthroposophy, Steiner's Occultist Sect Anthroposophical Medicine Camphill (residential care for developmentally disabled) Biodynamic Agriculture Goethean Science Racism and the Relationship of Anthroposophy to Nazi Philosophy Church-State issues with Public Waldorf Schools PLANS lawsuit documents Other lawsuits - documents
Date	Title and Author
Waldorf in General, Description & Critique
November, 2008	Clues: Piercing the Waldorf Facade by former Waldorf pupil Roger Rawlings. "How can you tell what a Waldorf school is up to? There are Waldorfs and Waldorfs. Very few of the schools will openly acknowledge that they are devoted to occultism. This denial may be true at some of the schools; in other cases, it is surely not true. So how can you tell whether unspoken occult beliefs are present in any particular Waldorf?" (external link)
July, 2008	A Pedagogy for Aryans by Peter Bierl. Small classes, no mad scramble for high marks, and a motivated teaching-staff—Waldorf schools have earned a good reputation for their feigned ability to benefit students on an individual level. Still, to this day, these disguised religious schools pursue the idea of the anti-modern.
September, 2007	Pädagogik der runden Ecken -- Kleine Klassen, kein Notendruck und eine motivierte Lehrerschaft – Waldorfschulen stehen in dem Ruf, Schüler individuell fördern zu können. Doch die verkappten Religionsschulen verfolgen bis heute die Idee der Antimoderne. Von Peter Bierl. (external link) English Summary
July 28, 2007	Questions about Steiner's classroom by Melinda Rout, The Australian (external link)
May 15, 2007	Advice for Parents by former Waldorf pupil Roger Rawlings. (external link)
December 5, 2006	Warm and Woolley? An anthroposophical experiment. By Kristín A. Sandberg and Trond K. O. Kristoffersen.
Current on the web	Denken strengt Verstand an – Pädagogik nach Rudolf Steiner. by Peter Bierl. Kontext: web site of Gerhard Kern. (external link, in German.)
Current on the web	Om Waldorfpedagogiken (in Swedish, external link).
February 13, 2006	Anthroposophy, Rudolf Steiner, and Waldorf Schools An article in The Skeptic's Dictionary by Robert Todd Carroll, last updated February 13, 2006
May, 2004	What's Waldorf? The alternative school's holistic, arts-based philosophy seemed like a perfect fit for my kids. Then I started learning about the eccentric mystical beliefs of its founder. By Meagan Francis, in Salon (external link).
2003	Why Waldorf Programs are Unsuitable for Public Funding by Dan Dugan, published by Cultic Studies Review, Volume 2, Number 2
2003	Spotlight on Anthroposophy By Sharon Lombard, published by Cultic Studies Review, Volume 2, Number 2, reproduced by permission
Nov. 16, 2002	Gnomes and Critics at Waldorf Schools. By Carol Milstone, National Post (Canada).
December 21, 2001	Question: Who Was Rudolf Steiner? Answer: Who Is Asking? By Steve Walden
December 21, 2001	The Role of Gnomes In Waldorf Kindergarten By Diana Winters
June 20, 2001	The Spirit of Waldorf Education written by David Ruenzel, Education Week, June 20, 2001
(not dated)	Waldorf Schools, Anthroposophy, and Rudolf Steiner A concise description, including good list of sources. Cincinnati Skeptics, The Association for Rational Thought
September 1, 2000	Mein Konflikt mit meiner Anthroposophischen Erziehung A German article by Christoph Keller dated September 1, 2000
November 13, 1999	Waldorf Education--For Our Times Or Against Them? Transcript of talk by Eugene Schwartz, Director of Teacher Training, Sunbridge College: November 13, 1999. Edited by Michael Kopp.
October 1999	Letter To Editor by Kathleen Sutphen re Todd Oppenheimer's Atlantic Monthly article "Schooling the Imagination (Atlantic 9/99).
February 8, 1999	A Parent's List Of Questions And Concerns. By Steve Premo via post to waldorf-critics discussion list.
November 21, 1998	An Interview With PLANS President. by college student Jeff Horseman.
November 2, 1998	Critical Waldorf Article For Minnesota Parent Thwarted. By Mary Petrie.
Fall 1998	"Partial Vision in Alternative Education" by Ron Miller, Renewal: Fall 1998, Vol. 7 No. 2, p. 20.
April 3, 1990	Survey of San Francisco Waldorf School Parents: Report. by Dan Dugan, April 3, 1990.
June 4, 1989	Childhood in a Cocoon by Sara Solovitch (San Jose Mercury News): "The children who attend Waldorf schools are sheltered from the outside world's noise and haste. So what happens to them when childhood ends?"
	return to top
Personal Stories of Former Waldorf Parents, Students, Teachers, Administrators
August 27, 2008	Waldorf har en dold andlig agenda (in Swedish) by Hasse Boström. Alicia - själv tidigare Waldorfelev - tillhör ett internationellt nätverk som granskar antroposofin. Dagen, 1 September 2008 (external link).
July 6, 2008	A Very Alternative Education by Northernrefugee. One mother's discovery of the good, the bad, and the ugly at one of the world's leading Waldorf schools.
June 9, 2008	An Open Letter to Highland Hall by Pete Karaiskos. An example of how people who believe they are on a Mission from God can abuse someone who suggests cleaning their own house first.
March 31, 2008	Selections from the Green Parent Forum. Bullying, rigidity, control-freakery, you name it.
June 7, 2007	Testimonial of a Former Waldorf Parent. By Anonymous #4.
February 1, 2007	UNENLIGHTENED: The Inside Story of an Occult Education by Roger Rawlings (external link).
July 15, 2004	Disillusioned ex-Waldorf parent: posting to the waldorf-critics list by Margaret Sachs.
March 4, 2004	Testimonial: Sent to the PLANS webmaster.
December 21, 2001	Anonymous Testimonial From Waldorf Parent. By Anonymous #1.
December 21, 2001	Anonymous Testimonial From Waldorf Parent. By Anonymous #3.
December 19, 2001	Parent Testimonial in waldorf-critics Post. By Kathy H.
April 2, 2000	Anonymous Testimonial From Waldorf Parent. By Anonymous #2.
January 31, 2000	Thanks PLANS! Email From Sharon Lombard. By Sharon Lombard.
January 12, 2000	Woman Sees Waldorf Racism On First Visit. By Anonymous.
September 11, 1999	Waldorf Student Testimonial - Rosie. By Rosie.
1999	The phlegmatic sits by the window...: Experiences with actual Waldorf teaching. Miss Claudia Pangh, published by Reinhard Karst, 1999.
December 4, 1998	A Note Of Thanks. By [name withheld by request].
February 4, 1998	My Education Towards Racism. By Edwin Kreulen.
October 8, 1997	"We don't need no Steiner education." Pink Floyd leader David Gilmour speaks his mind about his children's Waldorf experience. An article by Cassandra Jardine, Education section, The Daily Telegraph, 10-08-1997, pp 22.
April 1996	Warten auf die Reinkarnation von Jesus und Steiner in einer Person. MIZ interview with Norbert Biermann, April 1996. In German followed by a rough machine translation.
Fall 1991	Weird Science At Steiner School. Skeptical Inquirer, Vol. 16 (Fall 1991), page 23. Dan Dugan's personal story.
	return to top
	Quotations About Waldorf and Anthroposophy by Rudolf Steiner and Others
June 1, 2007	What We're Made Of: Steiner on anatomy and physiology, collected and analyzed by Roger Rawlings (external link).
September 2002	Quotations by Rudolf Steiner and others on the spiritual importance of color and art, compiled by Sharon Lombard.
January 2001	Wet-on-wet Painting As Talisman, a series of posts to waldorf-critics by Sharon Lombard, January 11, 2001 - January 22, 2001.
September 1996	The Roots of Racism in Waldorf Schools: Quotations from Rudolf Steiner and other Anthroposophists compiled by Dan Dugan, July 1995, revised September 1996.
	return to top
Waldorf Curriculum and Anthroposophy in the Classroom
June 1, 2007	What We're Made Of. Steiner on anatomy and physiology, collected and analyzed by Roger Rawlings (external link).
December 7, 2006	It's About Anthroposophy by Baandje. Posted to the waldorf-critics list, December 7, 2006
November 8, 2006 & following comments	"Woo Math: Steiner and Theosophical Math." Thread on the Good Math, Bad Math blog. (external link)
April, 2005	Poor Academic Standards by MQ. Posted to the waldorf-critics list, April 19, 2005
January 2001	Wet-on-wet Painting As Talisman, a series of posts to waldorf-critics by Sharon Lombard, January 11, 2001 - January 22, 2001.
May 2000	Our Brush with Rudolf Steiner by Sharon Lombard. Freethought Today. Madison, WI: May 2000, p. 8.
July 27, 1997	Nature Table or Altar?: by Dan dugan, July 27, 1997.
1996	Mathematikunterricht an Freien Waldorfschulen: [221K .pdf file in German] by Susanne Prediger & Heiner Ullrich. Journal für Mathematikdidaktik 17 (1996) 3/4, S. 192-211.
Spring 1994	Are Rudolf Steiner's Waldorf Schools 'Non-Sectarian'? by Dan Dugan and Judy Daar, Free Inquiry, Spring 1994 (Vol. 14 No. 2
Winter 1994	Waldorf Schools Teach Odd Science, Odd Evolution by Eugenie C. Scott. National Center for Science Education Reports, Vol. 14, No. 4, Winter 1994, p. 20
	return to top
Waldorf Teacher Training
October 8, 2008	University of Stockholm dumps Waldorf teacher training program: not up to standards of higher education. By Alicia Hamberg. A survey of the controversy, quoting sources on both sides.
August 26, 2008	Stockholm University ends Steiner teacher training. Stockholm University has decided to wind up its Steiner-Waldorf teacher training. Steiner science literature is 'too much myth and too little fact', the university's teacher education committee has ruled. The Local: Sweden's News in English (external link).
June 19, 2008	University of Stockholm Rejects Waldorf Courses. (in Swedish) The University of Stockholm has decided not to support 11 Waldorf-related courses that had previously been given as parts of the Waldorf teacher training.The Swedish Sceptics' association reports that this decision is part of a greater general effort to ensure and enhance the quality of the teacher training programs. (external link)
Current	CURRICULUM of the Bay Area Center for Waldorf Teacher Training
August 24, 2005	Anti-social and Alienating Behavior. A Waldorf teacher gives some background that helps in understanding the behavior of Waldorf teachers. Posted to the waldorf-critics discussion list by Baandje.
July 3, 2005	Karma and Reincarnation for Teachers: Caring for Relationships. by Dr. Robin Bacchus, Teachers Preparatory Course Coordinator, Taruna College, New Zealand.
July/August, 2004	Wundersame Waldorf-Pädagogik oder Atlantis als Bewusstseinszustand by Andreas Lichte (in German) An experience in a Waldorf teacher-training course. Rough translation: Wondrous Waldorf Pedagogy or Atlantis as State of Consciousness by Andreas Lichte
1993-1994	Waldorf Teacher Training Reading List, First Year: Rudolf Steiner College 1993-94.
1993-1994	Waldorf Teacher Training Requirements, Second Year: Rudolf Steiner College 1993-94.
	return to top
Anthroposophy, Steiner's Occultist Sect
July 14, 2008	Steiner and the Warlord by former Waldorf student Roger Rawlings. "As an amazingly gifted clairvoyant, Rudolf Steiner should have foreseen—before the first German boot trod upon Belgian soil in 1914—the dreadful carnage to come as well as its horrific results. Yet he associated himself with the leader of Germany's military, a man who might fairly be described as a war criminal." (external link)
2007	Anthroposophy, by Dan Dugan. An article in The New Encyclopedia of Unbelief from Prometheus Press.
September 3, 2006	Anthroposophy 101 by Ronald Koetsch, posted to the waldorf-critics list 9/3/06, as published in Renewal, Spring/Summer 2006
July, 2006	Bibliography on the Applicability of "Occultism" As a Description of Anthroposophy, by Peter Staudenmaier on the waldorf-critics list, July 20, 2006 "Re: the meaning of occultism."
January, 2006	Dweller on the Threshold On the 80th anniversary of Rudolf Steiner's death, Gary Lachman celebrates the life, work and enduring legacy of one of Western esotericism's most ambitious and unusual thinkers. External link to Fortean Times.
May, 2004	Anthroposophy, Rudolf Steiner and Waldorf/Steiner Schools: Collected references from the National Library of Australia. An annotated bibliography by Trevor Lee. (79 KB .pdf)
January 28, 2001	Anthroposophy: by Fredrik Bendz, July 4, 1997, last update January 28, 2001.
February 9, 1999	Why Anthroposophy Is Cult-Like by Dan Dugan.
Spring, 1998	Caring for the Family of Cult Victims by Ian Haworth, Cult Information Centre (UK).
April 1996	Anthroposophy: Rudolf Steiner's 'Spiritual Science': by Rob Boston, Church and State, April 1996.
1991	Is Anthroposophy Science? by Sven Ove Hansson, Conceptus: zeitschrift für philosophie, XXV (1991), No. 64, p. 37.
December, 1982	Five Karmas, or Anthroposophy in Great Britain by Dr. Geoffrey Ahern. An in-depth sociological analysis of the Steiner group and their doctrines (external link).
	See also: links return to top
Anthroposophical Medicine
March 19, 2008	Measles Epidemic (in German) A large outbreak of measles in Salzburg, Austria has been reported. ...at a Waldorf school in Salzburg. The the local health department is trying to limit the damage by offering information and recommending vaccination for all children at the school who are not yet vaccinated. Apparently, in Nordrhein-Westfalen were the latest large epidemic occurred, out of 2000 infected, one child died and there's evidence of lasting damage due to encephalitis among the survivors (external link).
February 25, 2007	Steiner's Quackery by former Waldorf student (11 years) Roger Rawlings (external link).
January 30, 2007	Growing Up Being Made Sick by Anthroposophy by Robert Smith-Hald.
December 23, 2006	"Mistletoe as a treatment for cancer: Has no proved benefit, and can cause harm." By Edzard Ernst, BMJ 2006:333; 1281-1283. (external link)
December 23, 2006	"Subcutaneous inflammation mimicking metastatic malingnancy induced by injection of mistletoe extract." By A.I. Finall, S.A. McIntosh, W.D. Thompson, BMJ 2006:333; 1293-1294. (external link)
December 6, 2006	Anthroposophic Medicine by Robert Todd Carroll. Skeptics Dictionary (external link).
December 21, 2004	Mistletoe - viable alternative cancer treatment, or just a placebo with dangerous side-effects? Edzard Ernst in The Guardian (external link).
September 13, 2002	The Deadly Perils of Rejected Knowledge by Thomas R. DeGregori. American Council on Science and Health. (external link)
September 2002	Bucking The Herd by Arthur Allen: Atlantic Monthly article on a vaccination controversy in Boulder, Colorado (external link).
1997	Anthroposophical Medicine by William Jarvis, PhD, National Council Against Health Fraud (external link).
	return to top
Camphill
July 4, 2008	Child Abuse Charges against Berlin Waldorf Facility by Peter Tiede, Tagesspiegel. In English and German.
Current on the web	Musical Biography by Robert Smith-Hald. What life was like for a boy growing up as the child of Camphill staff (external link).
Current on the web	Camphill Training Course in Curative Education and Social Therapy
October 12, 2004	Paradise Trust: statement of the results of an Inquiry under Section 8 of the Charities Act 1993.
January, 1992	Wandin Springs Report released by the Australian Department of Human Services in response to a Freedom of Information request.
	See also: links return to top
Biodynamic Agriculture
November 18, 2008	Voodoo on the Vine by Joe Eskenazi. The origins of the increasingly popular Biodynamic wine are steeped in the occult and bad science. SF Weekly (external link).
February 25, 2007	Fill Those Cow Horns. Essay by former Waldorf student Roger Rawlings (external link).
June 9, 2006	"Biodynamics" in The World of Fine Wine: Join the Debate. A continuing blog discussion. (external link)
February 11, 2006	How to practice Biodynamics...? Blog in The Zinquisition series by "St. Vini." (external link)
February 3, 2005	Book review: Wine, from sky to earth (Joly). Blog in The Zinquisition series by "St. Vini." (external link)
August, 2004	James Randi's opinion on "Preparation 500" (external link).
	return to top
Goethean Science
1922	Steiner and Natural Science. One of the most prominent physicists of Steiner's era, Max von Laue, who received the Nobel Prize for physics in 1914, wrote a scathing critique in 1922 of Steiner's misunderstandings of science and particularly of physics. Transition no. 61-62, pp. 160-165. Collingwood, Vic, Australia, 2000. (.pdf) Use back button to return here.
	return to top
Racism and the Relationship of Anthroposophy to Nazi Philosophy
June 8, 2008	Anthroposophists and Antisemitism in Fascist Italy by Peter Staudenmaier. The surprising story of how a co-founder of the Anthroposophical Society in Italy played a leading role in the persecution of Italian Jews.
current on the web	'Ecology' and the Modernization of Fascism in the German Ultra-right by Janet Biehl (external link). Includes an analysis of the role of Anthroposophists in contemporary Neo-Nazi movements--see the section "Anthroposophy and the World League for the Protection of Life."
January, 2008	The Art of Avoiding History: a reply that Peter Staudenmaier wrote to Göran Fant's article "The Art of Making White into Black." Both articles were originally published in the Swedish skeptical-humanist magazine Folkvett in 2001. "... this is the one I revised most thoroughly and expanded most extensively; it now includes much more material. Even those who have read it before might find interesting new things in it."
December, 2007	Anthroposophy and Ecofascism by Peter Staudenmaier. An update of his 2000 article.
December, 2007	Anthroposophy and its Defenders by Peter Staudenmaier and Peter Zegers. An update of their 2000 article.
December, 2007	The Janus Face of Anthroposophy by Peter Staudenmaier and Peter Zegers. An update of their 2000 article.
July 25, 2007	Steiner education in State Schools -- Parent Ray Pereira: "...for example, the class wasn't allowed to use black or brown colours, it was only yellows and reds and certain colours that were allowed to be used. Now this was a little bit of a problem I guess for my kids because they see themselves as being brown, and therefore weren't allowed to colour themselves as brown..." Transcript of ABC (Australia) broadcast (external link).
Current on the Web	Waldorfschulen Anthroposophie, Waldorfschulen und ihre Adepten. By Gilbert Reis. Kontext (.pdf, in German).
Current on the Web	Theosophie und Anthroposophie--Eine philosophische Basis der Neuen Rechten, oder: Der (esoterische) Rassismus aus der besseren Gesellschaft. By Gerhard Kern, Kontext (external link, in German).
June/July 2005	The Racial Teachings of Rudolf Steiner by Sven Ove Hansson. External link to SkepticReport.com
October 10, 2004	Race and Redemption: Racial and Ethnic Evolution in Rudolf Steiner's Anthroposophy, by Peter Staudenmaier. Presented to the conference of the American Family Foundation, Atlanta, October 15, 2004. This article has been accepted by the University of California journal Nova Religio, and is not currently available from PLANS.
August 6, 2004	Waldorf in the Nazi era. Response posted to the waldorf-critics discussion list by Peter Staudenmaier, Aug 6, 2004.
1997 - 2001	Anthroposophie und Antisemitismus: Frequently updated: articles in German from 1997 to the present on the web page of Aktion Kinder des Holocaust.
August 4, 2000	Intimidation of the Waldorf kind. An article written by Arno Frank that appeared August 4, 2000 in German publication TAZ, translated into English by CISAR.ORG
July 10, 2000	Report Mainz: July 10th, 2000: an unauthorized translation of the news broadcast shown on German national TV on July 10th, 2000 about racism in Waldorf schools.
Spring, 1999	Three people reflect on Waldorf Education: Recollections, published in Natural Jewish Parenting, Spring 1999
Spring, 1999	Rudolf Steiner and the Jews by Dan Dugan, published in Natural Jewish Parenting, Spring 1999
Spring, 1999	What every Jewish parent should know about The Waldorf Philosophy by Deborah Salazar, published in Natural Jewish Parenting, Spring 1999
March, 1997	RUDOLF STEINER's ANTHROPOSOPHY, A NAZI CULT? by Peter Nasselstein. A probing analysis from a devotee of Wilhelm Reich. External link to www.w-reich.de.
1995 - 1997	Antroposofie: [in Dutch] A collection of articles from the Dutch anti-racist paper Kleintje Muurkrant.
September, 1996	The Roots of Racism in Waldorf Schools: Quotations from Rudolf Steiner and other Anthroposophists compiled by Dan Dugan, July 1995, revised September 1996.
1996	Waldorf Salad with Aryan Mayonnaise?: A mother challenges 'race' theories in Rudolf Steiner education. By Toos Jeurissen, 1996.
June, 1996	Racism and Waldorf Education by Ray McDermott and Ida Oberman. Research Bulletin: Vol. 1, No. 2 (June, 1996) p. 3, Waldorf Education Research Institute.
November, 1995	Eternal Fascism: Fourteen Ways of Looking at a Blackshirt by Umberto Eco. Utne Reader, November-December 1995, pp. 57-59. This article doesn't specifically refer to Anthroposophy, but 11 of Eco's 14 points (excepting 7, 8, and 12) might easily be applied to Anthroposophy. External link to themodernword.com.
February 4, 1995	Racial Ethnography by Robert Sikkes. Zutphen, Netherlands. De Volkskrant, February 4, 1995.
1992	The Swedish anthroposophists and the "Negro problem" by Sven Ove Hansson. Folkvett 1992, No. 1.
	return to top
Church-State Issues with Public Waldorf Schools
January, 2008	The delusional world of Rudolf Steiner by Ian Hayward Robinson. Australian Rationalist, Issue 78 (external link). Front Cover
September 14, 2007	Steiner approach under review By Mary Gearin. One investigation relates to literacy and numeracy standards, and the other comes after some parents complained that the spirituality implicit in the Steiner system was incompatible with secular public education. Transcript of ABC broadcast (external link).
July 28, 2007	Questions about Steiner's classroom by Milanda Rout, The Australian (external link).
July 25, 2007	Steiner education in State Schools: Is it Occult? Steiner education in Victorian state Schools may be stretching the secular intent of Victoria's 1872 Education Act. The Act was the first in Australia to make education free, secular and compulsory. Transcript of ABC broadcast (external link).
July 15, 2007	Talkback: Who was Rudolf Steiner? Why the current controversy over Steiner education programmes in Victorian state schools? Transcript of ABC broadcast (external link).
Summer, 2006	Steiner Preschools: More Taxpayer-Funded Loopiness. By Raymond Richards. New Zealand Skeptics Newsletter.
September 22, 2005	Change of PLANS: Waldorf foes will try their luck in another court. (External link: Sacramento News & Review)
February 3, 2005	Schooled in spirituality: The Waldorf charter schools tend toward the metaphysical in approach, but is that religious teaching? A federal-court judge will decide. (External link: Sacramento News & Review)
February 4, 2004	Letter from the Anthroposophical Society to the Benicia, CA, School Board: Anthroposophists compare PLANS to jewwatch.com!
2003	Why Waldorf Programs are Unsuitable for Public Funding by Dan Dugan, Cultic Studies Review, Volume 2, Number 2
October 28, 2003	Minutes of the Ross Valley School District Board, denying Oak Mountain Waldorf Charter School Petition : October 28, 2003.
Nov. 16, 2002	Gnomes and Critics at Waldorf Schools. By Carol Milstone, National Post (Canada).
March 27, 2001	Appeals Court Decision: Altman vs. Bedford Central School District : March 27, 2001.
February 7, 2001	Findings of the Chico Unified School District Board, denying Blue Oak Waldorf Charter School Petition : February 7, 2001.
October 30, 2000	Religion or Philosophy? Critics say Waldorf schools' unusual methods make them ineligible for public funding An article appearing October 30, 2000 on the front page of The San Francisco Chronicle.
October 7, 1999	WCBM "Uninhibited Radio" Transcript of radio program on Waldorf Education and PLANS' lawsuit, October 7, 1999 on WCBM Baltimore, Maryland, U.S.A. Host: Les Kinsolving. Guests: Dan Dugan, People for Legal and Nonsectarian Schools (PLANS); Betty Staley, Rudolf Steiner College; David Alsop, Association of Waldorf Schools of North America.
October 1, 1999	Public Schools Teaching Occult Religion?: Lawsuit challenges tax funding of New Age curriculum by Stephan Archer, WorldNetDaily.com October 1, 1999.
1999	Reading, Writing, and "Spiritual Science"? by John W. Morehead.
1997	New Age Education Supported By Public Tax Dollars? Waldorf Charter School Controversy by John W. Morehead
Winter, 1997	Going Public: Schools weigh the Waldorf alternative: by Nora Mealy, California Schools: Winter 1997
March 4, 1997	Twin Ridges School - A Deceptive Alternative: by Dr. James M. Morton. The Union, Grass Valley-Nevada City, CA, March 4, 1997.
June 28, 1996	AWSNA Position Statement: ("Waldorf education is only possible if its practitioners and administrators are free to work out of a clear recognition of and commitment to the development of the spiritual nature of the human being.") June 28, 1996.
June 25, 1996	Americans United to Novato School Board: Letter from John C. Barker, June 25, 1996.
April, 1996	Charter for Indoctrination?: Why a San Diego Teacher Gives Tax-Funded Waldorf Charter Schools An 'F' by Rob Boston, Church and State, April 1996.
July 6, 1995	General Counsel to San Diego School Board: Letter of July 6, 1995, re Tubman Village School
April 27, 1995	Separation of Guru and State? - Influence of the New Age Movement on Public Education: by Francis J. Beckwith. PREMISE , Vol. II, No. 4 (April 27, 1995) p. 8
March, 1992	The Rudolf Steiner Threat to Victorian Education by Ian Robinson. From: The Australian Rationalist, No 30, March 1992. If the Australian authorities had listened to Robinson back in '92, they wouldn't be in the trouble they are with Waldorf today.
	return to top
PLANS Lawsuit Documents
November 11, 2007	UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT - MEMORANDUM (16KB .pdf file). "The district court erred in excluding the testimony of the witnesses in question. Because PLANS intended to call the witnesses as percipient witnesses, it did not need to comply with the court's deadline for expert witness disclosure. Moreover, the record indicates that PLANS disclosed the witnesses as early as January 2001. Even if the witnesses had not been properly disclosed, there was no prejudice as the School Districts had previously designated the same witnesses as expert witnesses. ...Accordingly, the judgment of the district court is REVERSED, and the case is REMANDED for further proceedings."
November 3, 2005	254 NOTICE OF APPEAL TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEAL FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT (3.1MB .pdf file)
September 28, 2005	248 FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW; AND ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR JUDGMENT UNDER FEDERAL RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 52(c) (24K .pdf file)
September 12, 2005	241.1 Transcript of Trial (52K .pdf file)
April 20, 2005	229 THIRD AMENDED PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER (872K .pdf file)
March 25, 2005	227 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF MICHELLE L. CANNON IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONS IN LIMINE (28K .pdf file)
March 25, 2005	225 DEFENDANTS' JOINT REPLY TO PLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO MOTION IN LIMINE NO. THIRTEEN (13) TO EXCLUDE EXPERTS NOT PROPERLY DISCLOSED BY PLAINTIFF (48K .pdf file)
March 25, 2005	224 DEFENDANT'S JOINT REPLY TO PLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO MOTION IN LIMINE NO. TWELVE (12) TO EXCLUDE EXHIBITS NOT PREVIOUSLY DISCLOSED OR PRODUCED (40K .pdf file)
March 25, 2005	223 DEFENDANTS' JOINT REPLY TO PLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO MOTION IN LIMINE NO. ELEVEN (11) TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY BY WITNESSES NOT PREVIOUSLY DISCLOSED (28K .pdf file)
March 18, 2005	221 OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' JOINT MOTION IN LIMINE NO. THIRTEEN (13) TO EXCLUDE "EXPERTS" (20K .pdf file)
March 18, 2005	220 OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' JOINT MOTION IN LIMINE NO. TWELVE (12) TO EXCLUDE DOCUMENTS (32K .pdf file)
March 18, 2005	219 OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' JOINT MOTION IN LIMINE NO. ELEVEN (11) TO EXCLUDE WITNESSES (36K .pdf file)
March 16, 2005	218 AMENDED PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER (100K .pdf file)
March 14, 2005	217 OBJECTIONS BY DEFENDANT SACRAMENTO CITY UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT TO PORTIONS OF THE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER FILED FEBRUARY 18, 2005 (512K .pdf file)
March 14, 2005	216 DEFENDANT TWIN RIDGES ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DISTRICT'S OBJECTIONS TO PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER (52K .pdf file)
March 11, 2005	211 DECLARATION OF MICHELLE L. CANNON IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONS IN LIMINE (32K .pdf file)
March 11, 2005	210 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. THIRTEEN: DEFENDANTS' JOINT MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EXPERTS NOT PROPERLY DISCLOSED BY PLAINTIFF (48K .pdf file)
March 11, 2005	209 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. TWELVE: DEFENDANTS' JOINT MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EXHIBITS NOT PREVIOUSLY DISCLOSED OR PRODUCED (52K .pdf file)
March 11, 2005	208 MOTION IN LIMINE NO. ELEVEN: DEFENDANTS' JOINT MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY BY WITNESSES NOT PREVIOUSLY DISCLOSED (52K .pdf file)
March 11, 2005	207 DEFENDANTS' JOINT NOTICE OF MOTIONS IN LIMINE (24K .pdf file)
February 18, 2005	206 PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER (684K .pdf file)
February 11, 2005	204 PLAINTIFF’S SEPARATE STATEMENT OF DISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS IN PREPARATION FOR PRETRIAL CONFERENCE (18K .pdf file)
February 11, 2005	203 JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STATEMENT (110K .pdf file)
January 28, 2005	202 NOTICE OF MOTIONS IN LIMINE AFFECTED BY PLAINTIFF’S MOST RECENT WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LISTS (20K .pdf file)
January 14, 2005	196 DEFENDANTS' FINAL PRETRIAL STATEMENT (810K .pdf file)
January 14, 2005	198 JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STATEMENT (85K .pdf file)
July 15, 2004	187 AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF OF THE ANTHROPOSOPHICAL SOCIETY IN AMERICA IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS (144K .pdf file)
June 25, 2004	161 MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF A MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY ADJUDICATION (116K .pdf file)
June 25, 2004	162 PLAINTIFF'S SEPARATE STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY ADJUDICATION (116K .pdf file)
May 28, 2004	163 DECLARATION OF JONATHAN P. HUBER IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY ADJUDICATION. (44K .pdf file)
February 10, 2003	109 OPINION from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, affirming the standing of PLANS and reinstating PLANS' federal lawsuit (44K .pdf file)
May 23, 2001	100 Full text of PLANS' lawsuit dismissal by The Honorable Frank C. Damrell May 23, 2001 (2.8 MB .pdf file)
October 24, 1999	49 Memorandum and Order: Decision of Judge Damrell 10/24/99 rejecting the school districts' request for summary judgment in PLANS' Establishment Clause lawsuit (2.2 MB .pdf file).
February 10, 1998	1 COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF: PLANS, Inc., Plaintiffs v. SACRAMENTO CITY UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, TWIN RIDGES ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DISTRICT, DOES 1 - 100, Defendants
	return to top
Other Lawsuits - Documents
August 26, 2004	UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT: No. 03-1626: CAMPHILL SOLTANE, Appellant v. US DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE; IMMIGRATION & NATURALIZATION SERVICE: An Anthroposophical institution claims that its employee is a religious worker. (72 KB .pdf file)
March 6, 2002	SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT AND JURY TRIAL DEMAND - RACIAL AND RETALIATORY DISCRIMINATION IN EMPLOYMENT: Charmaine Paulson, Plaintiff, -vs- Association of Waldorf Schools of North America (AWSNA) and Rudolf Steiner School of New York, Defendants. (2.6 MB .pdf file)
August 1, 2000	COMPLAINT FOR STATUTORY VIOLATIONS OF ADA, INTENTIONAL AND NEGLIGENT INFLICTION OF EMOTIONAL DISTRESS, CAL BUS & PROF CODE NEGLIGENCE, STATUTORY NEGLIGENCE OF CAL ED CODE: Blake and Betty Westman, Plaintiffs, -vs- Twin Ridges Elementary School District, Ken Ratekin, and DOES 1 - 50 inclusive, Defendants (2.4 MB .pdf file)

Contact PLANS

Personal Stories